Welcome to Prairie Cafe & Bakery, a delightful gem nestled in Middleton, Wisconsin. Located at 3109 Pheasant Branch Rd, this cafe has quickly established itself as a beloved destination for both locals and visitors alike. With its inviting atmosphere and thoughtfully curated menu, Prairie Cafe & Bakery is truly a must-visit spot for breakfast and lunch enthusiasts.
A glance at their menu reveals a vibrant selection of salads, soups, and quiches that cater to varied tastes. The Southwest Chicken Salad is a must-try, featuring succulent grilled chicken paired harmoniously with creamy avocado, crispy bacon, and an enticing corn pepper relish. It's no wonder customers rave about the quality of their dishes. The Chicken Caesar Salad and the rich, flavor-packed Chicken Greek Salad are equally enticing, showcasing Prairie Cafe's commitment to freshness and flavor—all priced at a reasonable $9.95.
The cafe is also known for its impressive drink menu, offering refreshing options like Iced Coffee and Cafe au Lait to complement any meal. For just $2.60 to $2.95, you can sip on a variety of beverages, making it the perfect spot to unwind.
Customer feedback has been overwhelmingly positive, with many praising the atmosphere and quality of food. As one guest, Milind Godbole, noted, Prairie Cafe & Bakery is especially popular during leisurely weekend mornings, thanks to its comfortable seating and well-structured menu. The combination of delicious chicken salads, delectable wraps, and hearty burgers, punctuated by freshly brewed coffee and indulgent milkshakes, leaves diners longing to return.
Wesley Newman described his visit as a delightful surprise, enjoying a blueberry scone while waiting for his pulled pork breakfast burrito, which was generously portioned and bursting with flavor. This kind of experience showcases the cafe's ability to deliver quality meals without the long wait, even during peak hours.
Prairie Cafe & Bakery not only excels in taste, but it also boasts a friendly staff dedicated to providing a memorable dining experience. As noted by Sab, the staff offers great recommendations and creates a warm ambiance that encourages patrons to return for their delicious offerings. Whether you're grabbing a cookie to go or enjoying a leisurely meal, the welcoming atmosphere of Prairie Cafe is bound to leave a lasting impression.
For those soul-searching moments over a warm drink or for a culinary adventure on a busy day, Prairie Cafe & Bakery stands ready to satisfy your cravings. Immerse yourself in the delightful flavors and inviting setting of this remarkable cafe—you won’t regret it!
We’d love to hear from you! Your email address will remain private. Required fields are marked *
Milind Godbole
03/08/2025
Excellent cafe very popular for breakfast and lunch on lazy weekends morning. Great location, seating, a very well laid out menu to select from. We ordered chicken salad, wrap and chicken burgers with coffee and milk shake. Portion and quality was top notch. Must visit if you are in Madison.
Wesley Newman
27/07/2025
Everything we tried was very good. We stopped in on a whim on a Sunday, and judging by the parking lot, we were worried we would have to wait for a seat, but they have plenty of seating inside. We ordered at the counter and got a scone to share while we waited for or food. The blueberry scone we got was good and tasted fresh, and we did not have to wait long for our food at all, despite how busy it was! We had a table near the counter and got to see all the dishes othe patrons ordered, and let's just say we will be back to try their sandwiches they looked so good. My pulled pork breakfast burrito was very good and big enough to feed 2 people(who had a scone) and my wife's scramble was good too!
G W
25/07/2025
June 7, 2025 Service with Mary Ellen was great. Never been here before. She explain somethings easily. We received our food. My only complaint is my eggs were not over medium. They were over easy. Otherwise everything else was not to bad.
Sab
19/07/2025
This Business is amazing. The coffee and the breakfast meals were delicious! Friendly staff and lots of great recommendations. The cookies are fun to grab to go ! Came back a second day so I wouldn't miss out on another good meal! Would come here if I was a local all the time
Jerry Murphy
20/06/2025
Food and service were outstanding. The atmosphere is a little yuppie-ish for my taste, but tolerable.
Lewie S
06/06/2025
I come here a lot because of the great food and atmosphere! The lady at the front always greets you with a smile and is always happy to see people! The food is always tasty and perfectly cooked!
Maria Hilgers
11/05/2025
Great staff and atmosphere! Eggs Florentine and Collectivo coffee never disappoint, nor do the kind, hard-working staff. If you're jonesing for a tasty breakfast in Middleton, look no further!
Sarah Barron
20/04/2025
I love the atmosphere at Prairie Cafe. There is a ton of light and it doesn’t feel cramped inside, even when busy. All around, I always know I’m going to have something I’ll really enjoy. The pancakes are delicious! I don’t know how they do it, but I’ve never had pancakes this moist. This is a great place to bring a small child or baby, too. They have high chairs and plenty of space to use them.